Captain, I'm not going to say it's equivalent to buffing compound...but it's a lot more forgivable! Toothpaste is a super mild abrasive, gel isn't. I lightly wet sand the area first with 400 or 600 paper then smear a small amount of toothpaste with a few drops of water over the same area. Rub with either a cloth pulled over your finger, or again, rub with a fine grade (600) of sandpaper and water. Rinse and feel the difference. When I`m satisfied I apply my next or final coats. Works for me.